Indiana Appellate Case on the Right to Resist a Police Officer’s Unlawful Entry

April 21st, 2010 admin
Share/Save/Bookmark

Add To Delicious Digg This post Stumble this post
Topics:

(Eugene Volokh) The case is Barnes v. State (Ind. Ct. App. Apr. 15, 2010) ; I’m not an expert on the field, so I don’t know how representative this is of the law throughout the country, but it struck me as interesting. The court’s conclusion: We reverse Barnes’s disorderly conduct conviction because the State failed to prove that Barnes’s noisy political expression was an abuse of his right to free speech. We also reverse Barnes’s convictions for battery on a law enforcement officer and resisting law enforcement, but we …


Originally posted on Volokh

 
  Related Posts
Massachusetts Trial Court Holds That “Safe Storage” Law Bars Storage in a Locked Box That Is in a Place from Which It Could Be Easily Stolen; Appellate Court Disagrees
(Eugene Volokh) It’s Commonwealth v. Lojko (Mass. App. Ct.), decided today (one paragraph break added): On February 20, 2008, Hyannis police Officer Eugene Desruisseaux was dispatched to the defendant’s residence as a result of a report that the defendant was suicidal and was threatening to harm himself and others with a firearm. After speaking... 
Why Restrictions on Corporate Speech Reduce Political Equality
To my mind, the strongest argument for restrictions on corporate speech is that they promote political equality. Unlike the far weaker argument that corporations aren’t entitled to free speech because they aren’t people , the equality argument correctly assumes that corporations are actually just tools used by people. It then holds that restricting... 
"Conrad Black’s lawyers, federal prosecutors clash over 2007 conviction; Lawyers for former media baron say government can’t prove trial error was harmless"
“Conrad Black’s lawyers, federal prosecutors clash over 2007 conviction; Lawyers for former media baron say government can’t prove trial error was harmless”: Ameet Sachdev had this article yesterday in The Chicago Tribune. The Toronto Star reported yesterday that ” Conrad Black’s lawyers urge court to drop all convictions... 
Is Texas About to Execute (Another) Innocent Man?
There is strong, if not conclusive, evidence suggesting that Texas executed an innocent man, Cameron Todd Willingham .  Radley Balko reports that some fear the Lone Star state is about to do it again in the case of Hank Skinner.  DNA testing of remaining evidence might put an end to such fears, and provide further evidence of Skinner’s evidence... 
Thoughts on the Reverse Yoo Hypothetical
The comments on the Reverse Yoo hypothetical are fascinating, and I wanted to try to draw some tentative conclusions from them. The most interesting result to me is that for a lot of Yoo’s critics, whether Yoo followed the law or not is mostly beside the point. The primary objection is that Yoo’s conduct permitted an act that they see as immoral.... 
But Officer, The Court Told Me To Ignore You
As for the handful of friends who’ve become judges and will still talk to me despite the things I write here, they react the same as anyone else when a police officer strolls up to them on the street and makes the good ol’ common law inquiry.  They know better than to play wise guy lawyer (or judge in their case), showing the cop how smart... 
Conservative Law Professor (and Former Tenth Circuit Judge) Michael McConnell Writes in Support of Elena Kagan’s Nomination
(Eugene Volokh) The letter is here . Among other things, McConnell argues in some detail that conservatives will likely be pretty happy about Elena Kagan on the freedom of religious and political speech, on free exercise of religion, and on the participation of religious institutions in generally available funding programs. (McConnell is on the pro–... 
An Unusual Exclusionary Rule Case
Wilson v. State , decided March 3 by the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals (the highest Texas court for criminal matters), involved two Texas statutes. The first is a Texas statutory exclusionary rule (Tex. Code Crim. Proc. § 38.23), first enacted in 1925: No evidence obtained by an officer or other person in violation of any provisions of the Constitution... 
Should People Acting through Corporations be Denied Constitutional Rights Because Corporations are “State-Created Entities”?
One of the standard arguments put forward by critics of the Supreme Court’s decision protecting corporate political speech in Citizens United is that people aren’t entitled to constitutional rights when they use corporate resources because corporations are “state-created entities.” If the state can create an entity, it supposedly also has the... 
Handling It Ourselves
The discussion about regulating lawyer free speech , as opposed to lawyers getting a half-way decent grip on how scummy their marketing can be in their race to the bottom, incorporates the notion of shaming those who are the root of the problem as a better way of handling matters than creating new laws that will deter free speech for everyone because... 
  Related Tweets from Twitter
VolokhC (Eugene Volokh)  : Beware of Greeks Bearing Bonds: I can?t begin to do justice to Michael Lewis? new story in Vanity Fair, Beware of ... http://bit.ly/aLlQ31..
Updated : 2010-09-10T03:26:33Z   |  Reply  |  View Tweet
ClarkAC01 (Andrew C. Clark)  : Is the DNC worried abt a candidate who was reelected w/ 68% of vote in '08 and who reps a district that gave Obama 69%? http://bit.ly/bV2Pit..
Updated : 2010-09-10T03:11:42Z   |  Reply  |  View Tweet
pennystockfree (Penny stocks tips)  : The Volokh Conspiracy An Optimistic Scenario for the Stock ... http://bit.ly/chc3GE..
Updated : 2010-09-10T02:28:59Z   |  Reply  |  View Tweet
livebsestocks (Live BSE Stocks)  : The Volokh Conspiracy An Optimistic Scenario for the Stock ... http://bit.ly/9f2Xwn..
Updated : 2010-09-10T02:28:59Z   |  Reply  |  View Tweet
livedowstocks (Live dow stocks)  : The Volokh Conspiracy An Optimistic Scenario for the Stock ... http://bit.ly/aJq3SR..
Updated : 2010-09-10T02:28:59Z   |  Reply  |  View Tweet
  Related News from Digg

Spam Protection by WP-SpamFree

TOP